One of my many objections to “progressivism” is its belief that government – the state – acts as a force for the public good superior to the “ordered anarchy” (the libertarian term for it) of individuals and markets unencumbered by the state. The arguments of progressives and statists, to even pretend any semblance of validity, must assume that the state behaves with objective disinterest to a degree greater than the society it governs. The flaw in this theory lies, or course, in the actors who maneuver the instruments of the state: human beings.
In December, two prominent New York state politicians were convicted on corruption charges. They were assessed fines and sentenced to prison terms. Justice fairly and rightly served, no? No. State laws in New York – which almost rivals Illinois in the breadth and depth of its political corruption – provide that both men (one Democrat, one Republican) receive their state pensions in spite of their criminal convictions:
“Despite their criminal convictions, two of New York’s former top lawmakers won’t be suffering financial hardship.
“Both former New York Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver and former Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos will be receiving sizeable pensions.
“The New York State Comptroller’s Office said Silver will get a monthly pension of just over $6,000. Skelos will receive just under $8,000 per month.
“Both men retired from their top political jobs just after their December 2015 convictions on federal corruption charges.
“Silver’s pension will add up to $79,222.68 per year. Skelos will get $95,831.52 per year.”
These pensions are funded by New York taxpayers. In spite of their criminal behavior, Silver and Skelos are still subsidized while in prison and for the remainder of their life by the very constituents they betrayed.
They are not alone. More than a dozen other criminal politicians in New York are being subsidized by taxpayers:
“…New York’s pension system is paying out about $531,000 per year to 14 other former state lawmakers and officials who have been convicted of a crime.”
To my progressive/statist readers I ask: where in the private sector, which you are so quick to belittle and control, will you find convicted criminals who are provided retirement benefits courtesy of taxpayers? You will not. Only those who control the levers of the state can grant themselves such grotesque and illiberal booty.
We owe no allegiance to any government or state which so criminally burdens us. Those who have forgotten who they serve deserve nothing but scorn and rebellion from those so ill-served.